- Bill Farmer and Nick Jameson (Hit the Road)
- Harvey Atkin and Robert Tinkler (animated series)
- David Nowlin and William Kasten (Telltale)
I thought it’d be interesting to hear who you all think works best as the pairing for Sam & Max voice actors, putting aside what you think of the surrounding game/show.
It’s a tricky one for me, since I think they’re all great and bring their own energy to each medium. Atkin and Tinkler are perfect in the animated series where everything is a bit hyper and amped up, but that probably wouldn’t work so well in the slower-paced games.
For me, I think the animated series voices are ever-so-slightly the best, but it’s really hard to choose. They’re all amazing in my opinion, though Nowlin/Kasten grew more into their performances and the characters as the seasons went on.